{ "summary": { "Queyranne": { "hits": 11, "attempts": 60, "hit_rate": 0.18333333333333332, "hit_rate_95_stratified_cluster_bootstrap": [ 0.1, 0.26666666666666666 ], "mean_gap_pct": 154.83176289252995, "median_gap_pct": 27.195113269358295, "max_gap_pct": 1377.371166540176, "median_recorded_sec": 0.00715179349998607 }, "SA": { "hits": 515, "attempts": 600, "hit_rate": 0.8583333333333333, "hit_rate_95_stratified_cluster_bootstrap": [ 0.8149999999999998, 0.8983333333333332 ], "mean_gap_pct": 2.367889415762393, "median_gap_pct": 0.0, "max_gap_pct": 133.62878030886412, "median_recorded_sec": 0.02274392250001256 }, "Uniform": { "hits": 214, "attempts": 600, "hit_rate": 0.35666666666666674, "hit_rate_95_stratified_cluster_bootstrap": [ 0.33333333333333337, 0.38166666666666665 ], "mean_gap_pct": 86.08754437452725, "median_gap_pct": 7.530200844438905, "max_gap_pct": 1081.239397320997, "median_recorded_sec": 0.00010332700000503792 }, "QAOA-p1": { "hits": 410, "attempts": 600, "hit_rate": 0.6833333333333332, "hit_rate_95_stratified_cluster_bootstrap": [ 0.6483333333333334, 0.7166666666666666 ], "mean_gap_pct": 9.623561585263518, "median_gap_pct": 0.0, "max_gap_pct": 384.3673309718967, "median_recorded_sec": 0.00010549099999934697 }, "QAOA-p2": { "hits": 457, "attempts": 600, "hit_rate": 0.7616666666666667, "hit_rate_95_stratified_cluster_bootstrap": [ 0.7233333333333333, 0.7983333333333335 ], "mean_gap_pct": 3.634689506642713, "median_gap_pct": 0.0, "max_gap_pct": 93.60959741276511, "median_recorded_sec": 0.00010467449999396194 } }, "by_size": [ { "n": 8, "instances": 15, "partitions_each": 127, "Jstar_min": 0.006498529457970247, "Jstar_max": 0.25780928505725653, "Jstar_median": 0.1302186548780447, "queyranne_hit_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "queyranne_hits": 5, "exact_median_sec": 0.008323776999986876, "queyranne_median_sec": 0.0029413999999974294, "SA_median_sec": 0.011496671999992714, "qaoa_p2_training_median_sec": 0.5045355219999692, "qaoa_p2_total_median_sec": 0.5134578179999494, "qaoa_p2_mean_pstar": 0.07464089511643661, "qaoa_p2_mean_lift": 9.47939367978745, "uniform_theoretical_hit256": 0.8678378833893103, "qaoa_p2_theoretical_hit256": 0.9968720861096956, "queyranne_median_calls": 119.0, "queyranne_median_unique": 43.0, "SA_hit_rate": 0.9933333333333334, "SA_hits": 149, "Uniform_hit_rate": 0.8733333333333334, "Uniform_hits": 131, "QAOA-p1_hit_rate": 1.0, "QAOA-p1_hits": 150, "QAOA-p2_hit_rate": 0.9866666666666667, "QAOA-p2_hits": 148 }, { "n": 10, "instances": 15, "partitions_each": 511, "Jstar_min": 0.007883160910674416, "Jstar_max": 0.2764414940536554, "Jstar_median": 0.048595175263470555, "queyranne_hit_rate": 0.2, "queyranne_hits": 3, "exact_median_sec": 0.032737908000001426, "queyranne_median_sec": 0.004925949000039509, "SA_median_sec": 0.02016195149997202, "qaoa_p2_training_median_sec": 0.5148216689999572, "qaoa_p2_total_median_sec": 0.5479608059999919, "qaoa_p2_mean_pstar": 0.04176415955207919, "qaoa_p2_mean_lift": 21.34148553111247, "uniform_theoretical_hit256": 0.39435986639778586, "qaoa_p2_theoretical_hit256": 0.8646301105674257, "queyranne_median_calls": 219.0, "queyranne_median_unique": 73.0, "SA_hit_rate": 0.9133333333333334, "SA_hits": 137, "Uniform_hit_rate": 0.4266666666666667, "Uniform_hits": 64, "QAOA-p1_hit_rate": 0.8666666666666668, "QAOA-p1_hits": 130, "QAOA-p2_hit_rate": 0.8399999999999999, "QAOA-p2_hits": 126 }, { "n": 12, "instances": 15, "partitions_each": 2047, "Jstar_min": 0.007174561635458964, "Jstar_max": 0.3191437134716356, "Jstar_median": 0.13968428840294997, "queyranne_hit_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "queyranne_hits": 1, "exact_median_sec": 0.13191779600003883, "queyranne_median_sec": 0.007530313000017941, "SA_median_sec": 0.02749584000000027, "qaoa_p2_training_median_sec": 0.6087296069999866, "qaoa_p2_total_median_sec": 0.7444020890000047, "qaoa_p2_mean_pstar": 0.01443056198935518, "qaoa_p2_mean_lift": 29.539360392210053, "uniform_theoretical_hit256": 0.11758395013183005, "qaoa_p2_theoretical_hit256": 0.7238341229624795, "queyranne_median_calls": 363.0, "queyranne_median_unique": 111.0, "SA_hit_rate": 0.8266666666666667, "SA_hits": 124, "Uniform_hit_rate": 0.10000000000000003, "Uniform_hits": 15, "QAOA-p1_hit_rate": 0.5933333333333335, "QAOA-p1_hits": 89, "QAOA-p2_hit_rate": 0.74, "QAOA-p2_hits": 111 }, { "n": 14, "instances": 15, "partitions_each": 8191, "Jstar_min": 0.0073630004528144975, "Jstar_max": 0.23847750653996277, "Jstar_median": 0.07340784684011013, "queyranne_hit_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "queyranne_hits": 2, "exact_median_sec": 0.561382741999978, "queyranne_median_sec": 0.011639915999978712, "SA_median_sec": 0.03499782800000162, "qaoa_p2_training_median_sec": 0.9930449590000308, "qaoa_p2_total_median_sec": 1.5286155549999876, "qaoa_p2_mean_pstar": 0.004935429984697791, "qaoa_p2_mean_lift": 40.4261070046596, "uniform_theoretical_hit256": 0.03077231255815689, "qaoa_p2_theoretical_hit256": 0.4978599378155629, "queyranne_median_calls": 559.0, "queyranne_median_unique": 157.0, "SA_hit_rate": 0.7000000000000001, "SA_hits": 105, "Uniform_hit_rate": 0.02666666666666667, "Uniform_hits": 4, "QAOA-p1_hit_rate": 0.2733333333333333, "QAOA-p1_hits": 41, "QAOA-p2_hit_rate": 0.48000000000000004, "QAOA-p2_hits": 72 } ], "comparisons": { "qaoa_p2_minus_uniform_observed_hit_rate": 0.405, "qaoa_p2_minus_uniform_observed_95_ci": [ 0.36666666666666664, 0.44333333333333336 ], "SA_minus_qaoa_p2_observed_hit_rate": 0.09666666666666666, "SA_minus_qaoa_p2_observed_95_ci": [ 0.055, 0.1366666666666667 ], "qaoa_p2_mean_pstar": 0.03394276166064218, "qaoa_p2_median_pstar": 0.012503733825762956, "qaoa_p2_median_pstar_lift_over_valid_uniform": 7.932463503684044, "qaoa_p2_lift_min": 0.3578942295802732, "qaoa_p2_lift_max": 134.122026121399, "qaoa_p2_mean_invalid_probability": 0.0007863068746365345, "qaoa_p2_mean_theoretical_hit256": 0.7707990643637911, "uniform_mean_theoretical_hit256": 0.3526385031192707, "qaoa_p2_nfev_min": 720, "qaoa_p2_nfev_max": 720, "qaoa_p2_nfev_sum": 43200, "qaoa_p1_nfev_sum": 28622, "non_submodular_instances": 60, "elementary_submodularity_inequalities_checked": 6804480, "max_covariance_relative_residual": 4.537084452155728e-15, "max_conditional_vs_joint_phi_difference": 7.105427357601002e-15, "exact_min_smaller_part_size": 1, "exact_max_smaller_part_size": 7, "ties_instances": 0 }, "totals": { "networks": 60, "partitions": 163140, "stochastic_trials": 2400, "readout_shots_per_qaoa_depth": 153600 }, "bootstrap": { "replicates": 10000, "unit": "network", "strata": "node count x family", "seed": 8890021 } }